ABSTRACT
After read several articles about the American crocodile, which is endangered in Florida, I became interested in it, because is been considering to down-listed the species from endangered to threatened because of it’s recovering in those areas. There is a controversy between The Fish and Wildlife Service and the environmentalist because they don’t agree about what to do with the American crocodile. I think that more research should be done about the reasons why the American crocodile migrate, become extinct and recover. Next, we could look for areas where the American crocodile could be move to, instead of kill some of them. Then, knowing the exact meaning of the words endangered and threatened, decide whether or not the American crocodile should be down-listed.

Recently sights of the American crocodile in Florida’s areas are showing that it is coming back. The American crocodile is recovering beaches of Boca Raton, Intercostals Waterway at Jupiter, Miami Beach, and shallows of Lake Worth and near the Mansion of Palm Beach. Actually, it is estimated that crocodile population ranges from 400 to 1000 adults (Moler, 2002). In 1975, the species was listed as endangered in Florida because of the hunting for the animal’s hide and the loss of habitat to development. Thus, in 1978, there were a total of 20 to 22 nests annually. Today there are between 40 and 50 nests annually (Moler, 2002). Therefore, is evident that the species is recuperating because there are up from approximately 200 to 400 more than twenty years ago (Daerr, 2000).
Moreover, is relevant to comment that there is a big issue about the relation between crocodile and people. Humans relate all kinds of crocodiles with aggression. In addition, People do not know the difference between American crocodile, Australian crocodile and alligators. These last two vary considerably from American crocodile, especially in their behavior. Alligators and crocodiles are the two native North American crocodilian species in the U.S. Crocodiles inhabit salt or brackish water, and alligators prefer freshwater. American crocodiles have a long, tapering, v-shaped snout—opposed to the u-shaped snout of the alligator. In addition, crocs have a distinguishing fourth tooth that protrudes prominently outside of the lower jaw when closed. The largest American crocodile was 15 feet, but they are routinely found at lengths of 8 to 12 feet. Consequently, the behavior would determinate whether if it is a danger for the society or not. American crocodiles are timid reptiles and are especially wary of people. Female crocs are known to completely abandon their nests after just a single disturbance. There are a few problems about the returning of the American crocodile, now there is people in those areas where the crocodile is recovering, and some people are afraid for their families and their owns, even if the American crocodile don’t represent a real danger for them. Therefore, there is a dilemma about the crocodile’s destiny and its place on the list of species.
Because the American crocodile is recovering in some areas of Florida, the Fish and Wildlife Service is recommending that the American crocodile be reclassified from “endangered” to “threatened”. However, the increasing crocodile population is threatening people, which they confuse with alligators so they want to kill some of them, but I think that we can find other ways to deal with the problem.
The species that are listed as endangered or threatened are protected by the Endangered Species Act (ESA), which says that we have to respect some rules about our interaction with those animals. "Unauthorized taking of a listed species can result in civil or criminal penalties"(Foreman, p.1, 2002). That means that we would receive a punishment if we break those rules. The ESA defines an endangered species as any species which is "in danger to extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its range. A threatened species is "one likely to become an endangered species within the foreseeable future throughout all or a significant portion of its range." (Foreman, p.2, 2002). In addition, is very important to know that the word "taking" include the following actions: to harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture, or collect, or to attempt to engage in any such conduct. These prohibitions are for "any person". "Person is defined broadly in the ESA, and includes government entities as well as individuals and business entities" (A Stanford Environmental Law Society Handbook, p.105, 2001). I found this quote very interesting because controversially I don't agree with that. The reason is that I think that sometimes the government, which we all know that have political and economical power, have done things against to animals without receiving any punishment. For example, the logging is a way to harm the animals. That destroy their habitat, which most of the time force those animals either to leave or to die. Some of them are listed, I believe that is an indirectly way to cause harm, but at the end, toward the animal, is harm. “Habitat destruction presents the greatest threat to the survival of species in United States and throughout the world” (The Law of Biodiversity and Ecosystem Management, p.245, 2002).
In order to decide if the species should be listed as endangered or threatened, The Fish and Wildlife Service must consider some factors as the numbers of a species and the possibilities to continue existing. However, it not includes considerations of economic effects of listing (Foreman, p.3, 2002). Consequently, we need to know the number of crocodiles in Florida. Actually, scientists estimates that there are around 800 to 1,000 crocodiles in Florida, which is a population that can double in the summer and fall when hatchlings appear, when 30 years ago, were just 200 American crocodiles living there (Mazzotti, 2000). We can see that the number of crocodiles in Florida is increasing, which is a good sign for a species that tottered toward extinction during the 20th century. In addition, is fundamental to know the possible reasons or causes that made the American crocodile to migrate, become extinct and recover Florida’s areas. The crocodile lives in underground hollow, large burrows, or in sand dunes. If the female crocodile is ready to lay her eggs but has no place to bury them, she will find an empty one; she will take it over as her own. However, Pollution, traffic, development, diseases, and predators could be some of those reasons. The development also could have cause that dredged canals have become crocodile favorites. Furthermore, there is a doubt about if the crocodile was forced to move because of the overpopulation. Scientifics have the theory that says that the migration of the crocodile could be a result of sustained population growth, in other words the crocodile population is outgrowing its existing habitat, and David Hitzig, of Busch Wildlife Sanctuary in Jupiter, he agrees with the scientist, but he has one more theory, which says that someone may have raised the crocodile illegally in captivity and decided to release them when they grew too big (Moler, 2002). Unlike Hitzig I believe that to be consider, the last theory is kind of absurd, because that could happen, but with a few people. Not all the crocodiles are covering Florida because their owners can’t stand them anymore. I mean, not everybody have a crocodile at home, I think most of the people don’t. Consequently, that theory shouldn’t be count at the time to discuss the possible reasons of the American crocodile’s recovering. On the other hand, I think that scientists should include in their investigations, about the crocodile case, the increasing of the numbers of people population in the state of Florida. If it were outgrowing its population habitat, the adult’s crocodiles would force the youngest ones to move or leave their territory. The young crocodiles would move and make a new nest. Seeming that there is not more natural places to go, crocodiles would migrate. In addition, another consideration could be that there might be people overpopulation in Florida, which would directly affect the crocodile’s state. The 2000 Census found 15,982,378 persons resident in Florida. This was an increase of 3,044,452 persons (23.5%) above the 1990 Census. The amount of increase was the third highest in the country. The rate of increase was the seventh highest in the country (Federation for the American Immigration Reform, 2000). Because of that, many species could seem forced to move somewhere else and may be that’s why the crocodiles have been seen more that two decades before. People are intimidated because they think that the crocodile is a danger for families and their own. Conversely, there is not a single known case of a crocodile injuring or killing a person, but there has been a record about alligators attack, and most of the people mistaken about which one is crocodile or alligator. Unlike alligators Crocodiles are very shy, non-aggressive, hard to catch and relatively timid when it comes to interactions with humans.
When I begun my investigation, I though that I should investigate more about the areas where the American crocodile could be removed to, considering the crocodile’s population there and the environment. So, I believed that it could be a good solution for the crocodile’s problem. However, since I started reading more about crocodiles, I found out that for animals to be removed is not an option. For most of the animals to be removed result frustrating. They just go crazy. Consequently, to move the animal from one to a different place is not good for their mind health. “The method used to catch alligators cannot be used for crocodiles because there is a possibility that they could die, according to Tim Regan, wildlife biologist for FFWCC. Instead, FFWCC is trying to throw a snatch hook into the crocodiles' thick hide to capture them. Regan stressed that because the hide is so thick, they would not be injuring the animals” (Garg, 2004). Part of the problem is that you relocate them and they come back. There is case in which a crocodile traveled 140 miles to return to the place from which it had been removed. "Somehow they navigate their way back." (Garg, 2004).
Biodiversity is the variability of all living organisms, including animal and plant species, of the genes of all these organisms, and of the terrestrial, aquatic, and marine ecosystems of which they are part. It is important because biodiversity makes up the structure of the ecosystems and habitats that support essential living resources, including wildlife, fisheries and forests. It helps provide for basic human needs such as food, shelter, and medicine. It composes ecosystems that maintain oxygen in the air, enrich the soil, purify the water, protect against flood and storm damage and regulate climate. Biodiversity also has recreational, cultural, spiritual and aesthetic values (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2003). Consequently, the crocodile as each species represent an equal importance to maintain the balance in the biodiversity, because if there is one extinct, the chain is broken. Everything is basically like a cycle.
I think that one of the solutions to solve this problem about the crocodile could be done by making Wildlife refuges and preserves which are another way to protect and save threatened and endangered species. I think that is the American crocodile shouldn’t be down-listed because since the species is making a come back we should learn about it, and don’t let them go away never again. Also, if there is not big difference between endangered and threatened, let the American crocodile stays in its place.